Showing posts with label Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN). Show all posts

Wednesday, December 02, 2009

Thoughtful comment on Medicaid and its improvement

Dr. James Baker is the CEO of Metrocare Services here in Dallas, Texas.

Metrocare Services, formerly known as the Dallas County Mental Health Mental Retardation (MHMR) Center, has served Dallas County for over 40 years by providing first rate clinical and social services to persons with mental illness, developmental disability, or severe emotional problems.


Jim is an expert on mental health care delivery among the poor and, thus, an expert on Medicaid.

Click here to refresh your memory on my previous post that addressed what I considered an outrageous comment about Medicaid made by Senator Lamar Alexander (TN-R).   Be sure and read the comments on that post. 

Here's what Dr. Baker left in the comment box on that earlier post: 

I want to go back to the original question by c hand: Why do "so few physicians...accept patients covered by the ... very good plan?" and why do patients with these plans have to wait for care?


Medicaid IS a very good plans from the perspective of its benefits, that is, what it will pay for. It is very generous in that respect.


The reason docs dont "accept patients" (actually it is the insurance that many dont accept...) is that Medicaid's reimbursement does not even cover most docs' costs for the services.


And if Congress doesnt repeal a Medicare reimbursement cut of 21% that is set for Jan 1st, the same access problems will worsen for the elderly that already happen for the poor.


The fix is counter-intuitive: increase both the number of people covered and the doc rates for both programs, so that access is easier and happens sooner in the course of a disease, so that the cost of each episode goes way down -- and therefore so does the total cost to taxpayers...


Unfortunately since it is counter-intuitive, many policymakers have a hard time grasping this reality...


Wednesday, November 25, 2009 3:30:00 PM CST

Jim, thanks for the clear and rational explanation. 

Ever consider a run for Congress?

Monday, November 23, 2009

"Medical ghetto"?

Even though I expect this post will set off a firestorm of comments, many or most of which will be very negative, I cannot find the words to properly express just how offensive I find the words of Senator Lamar Alexander (R-TN) during a speech he delivered in the current Senate health care debate.

Give him your attention.



In the first place, Medicaid represents the only health care option available to a portion, and only a portion, of the very poor in America. The major negative associated with Medicaid relates directly to the fact that so few physicians will accept patients covered by the otherwise very good plan.

As a result, my poorest neighbors must wait for care, and not only in long lines or in crowded clinic and ER waiting rooms, but for weeks at a time for scheduled treatment. This would be remedied if we had the benefit of a comprehensive, national health care plan.

But second, and even more offensive, if the good Senator feels that Medicaid is a "health care ghetto." doesn't he have a moral responsibility to improve it? Doesn't he have a fiscal responsibility to the nation to reform it, extend it and promote it? Hasn't he signed on as a national leader with the responsibilities that accompany such a decision? 

Never mind the obvious race baiting here. Let's talk quality, equity and health care justice, not to mention improving the nation's wellness and health outcomes across a broad array of health measures.

Senator, please!