Saturday, August 31, 2013
Friday, August 30, 2013
Thursday, August 29, 2013
Adjusting the effective minimum wage that YOU pay. . .
I've tried to imagine what it would be like to attempt to build a life on the earnings of the current, national minimum wage which is $7.25 an hour. No matter how you slice the challenge, providing the necessary support for a family or even for an individual while earning at the minimum is impossible.
Every few years we debate the issue in an attempt to adjust the baseline upward. The debate is so predictable that I'm not going to outline it here again.
I've got a better idea. Let's have the debate. Let's raise the minimum to a more appropriate level (Australia's minimum wage is $15.96).
But let's do something today about the low reward for labor among the poorest of our friends.
Here's my suggestion: wherever possible, when you purchase goods and services, calculate the value of the labor expended to bring you what you value enough to purchase. Once you've thought through this value proposition, pay off the unrewarded "value wage" of your transaction. In many retail settings this won't be possible or even necessary. But in many situations your "wage supplement," some will call it a "tip," can be determined and passed along with gratitude and affirmation of the worker who meets your needs. We say that we value labor. We want people to work, right? But how much do we really value labor?
For example, waiters usually earn minimum wage or less and count on gratuities to fill the wage gap. But there are many other places where I can adjust the minimum wage that I am willing to pay based on what the goods or services mean to me. How much do I value what is delivered to me?
Earlier this week I took my car to the tire shop for the repair of what was becoming a flat tire. In East Dallas at Carroll and I-30 you can get your tire repaired for $10. The afternoon was blazing hot. The young man who repaired my tire worked hard at the task at hand. He took pains to remove what appeared to be a fiberglass chard from the tire, allowing me to inspect the reason my tire was on the way down.
As he worked, I began to calculate the cost of his labor to his employer. With a unit of service in my case costing $10, I thought of the value that I placed on the service and the delivered product. I came up with a number well above the set price.
My equation was simple: set unit value + time required to deliver service + quality of service delivered + overall satisfaction with the service + what the service meant to me in terms of my need = value added gratuity or "wage adjustment."
Bottom line: I adjusted this young man's wage for my transaction.
While this doesn't solve the problem or move forward a solution to scale, it does provide me a meaningful way to do my part in engaging my economy for the sake of fairness and equity. By treating a worker at a time with fairness and equity, I proactively recognize the value provided by the working people who meet my many needs.
You can adjust the minimum wage paid laboring people today. Give it a try. I can tell you it definitely builds community and inspires working people.
Every few years we debate the issue in an attempt to adjust the baseline upward. The debate is so predictable that I'm not going to outline it here again.
I've got a better idea. Let's have the debate. Let's raise the minimum to a more appropriate level (Australia's minimum wage is $15.96).
But let's do something today about the low reward for labor among the poorest of our friends.
Here's my suggestion: wherever possible, when you purchase goods and services, calculate the value of the labor expended to bring you what you value enough to purchase. Once you've thought through this value proposition, pay off the unrewarded "value wage" of your transaction. In many retail settings this won't be possible or even necessary. But in many situations your "wage supplement," some will call it a "tip," can be determined and passed along with gratitude and affirmation of the worker who meets your needs. We say that we value labor. We want people to work, right? But how much do we really value labor?
For example, waiters usually earn minimum wage or less and count on gratuities to fill the wage gap. But there are many other places where I can adjust the minimum wage that I am willing to pay based on what the goods or services mean to me. How much do I value what is delivered to me?
Earlier this week I took my car to the tire shop for the repair of what was becoming a flat tire. In East Dallas at Carroll and I-30 you can get your tire repaired for $10. The afternoon was blazing hot. The young man who repaired my tire worked hard at the task at hand. He took pains to remove what appeared to be a fiberglass chard from the tire, allowing me to inspect the reason my tire was on the way down.
As he worked, I began to calculate the cost of his labor to his employer. With a unit of service in my case costing $10, I thought of the value that I placed on the service and the delivered product. I came up with a number well above the set price.
My equation was simple: set unit value + time required to deliver service + quality of service delivered + overall satisfaction with the service + what the service meant to me in terms of my need = value added gratuity or "wage adjustment."
Bottom line: I adjusted this young man's wage for my transaction.
While this doesn't solve the problem or move forward a solution to scale, it does provide me a meaningful way to do my part in engaging my economy for the sake of fairness and equity. By treating a worker at a time with fairness and equity, I proactively recognize the value provided by the working people who meet my many needs.
You can adjust the minimum wage paid laboring people today. Give it a try. I can tell you it definitely builds community and inspires working people.
Wednesday, August 28, 2013
Tuesday, August 27, 2013
Helpful comments
Across the years of my "blogging life" I've gone back and forth on moderating comments. For most of the time that I've posted here, I've allowed any comment to be posted on this site. Occasionally I've been forced to remove comments due to their highly offensive nature, but such action has been required on only a handful of occasions. It has always been my policy to remove commercial comments. In addition, I've welcomed comments from my "anonymous" friends and readers.
However, over the past couple of years the tone of a few readers has changed.
Comments often have nothing to do with what's been posted. Often comments display hateful attitudes that provide no helpful thoughts or useful content. Most of the offenders use my every post to lash out with political statements having absolutely nothing to do with what I'm discussing.
As a result of this change in comment content on the part of a few readers, I've decided to change my editorial policy.
Beginning today, all comments posted to my blog will be moderated/reviewed before being allowed on the page for everyone to read.
As always, comments posted in opposition to ideas contained in what I post will be welcomed. Honest, respectful debate will be encouraged on any subject or statement that I make or post here. Comments far afield of the subject at hand will be blocked.
In addition, hateful, disrespectful, outrageous and/or offensive comments will not be allowed onto my page.
While I encourage all readers to post their names to the comments offered, I will continue to accept anonymous comments which pass the test outlined here.
Thanks for following the conversation here. I will do my best to release all of your helpful comments and ideas in a timely manner.
However, over the past couple of years the tone of a few readers has changed.
Comments often have nothing to do with what's been posted. Often comments display hateful attitudes that provide no helpful thoughts or useful content. Most of the offenders use my every post to lash out with political statements having absolutely nothing to do with what I'm discussing.
As a result of this change in comment content on the part of a few readers, I've decided to change my editorial policy.
Beginning today, all comments posted to my blog will be moderated/reviewed before being allowed on the page for everyone to read.
As always, comments posted in opposition to ideas contained in what I post will be welcomed. Honest, respectful debate will be encouraged on any subject or statement that I make or post here. Comments far afield of the subject at hand will be blocked.
In addition, hateful, disrespectful, outrageous and/or offensive comments will not be allowed onto my page.
While I encourage all readers to post their names to the comments offered, I will continue to accept anonymous comments which pass the test outlined here.
Thanks for following the conversation here. I will do my best to release all of your helpful comments and ideas in a timely manner.
Sunday, August 25, 2013
To build "the whole"
In short, no pattern is an isolated entity. Each pattern can exist in the world, only to the extent that is supported by other patterns: the larger patterns in which it is embedded, the patterns of the same size that surround it, and the smaller patterns which are embedded in it.
This is a fundamental view of the world. It says that when you build a thing you cannot merely build that thing in isolation, but must also repair the world around it, and within it, so that the larger world at that one place becomes more coherent, and more whole; and the thing which you make takes it place in the web of nature, as you make it.
This is a fundamental view of the world. It says that when you build a thing you cannot merely build that thing in isolation, but must also repair the world around it, and within it, so that the larger world at that one place becomes more coherent, and more whole; and the thing which you make takes it place in the web of nature, as you make it.
Christopher Alexander, et. al.
A Pattern Language: Towns, Buildings, Construction, page xiii
(New York: Oxford University Press, 1977)
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
Flying without a net. . .
One of the real "upside" factors of my work is the board of directors serving and providing governance to our organization.
These wonderful men and women give so freely and sacrificially of their time, talent, money, ideas, commitment and encouragement. I recognize how fortunate I am to have the opportunity to work alongside such an amazing group of people.
At virtually every meeting of our board something encouraging, insightful, surprising and challenging comes up or is said. Most of the really exceptional stuff just arises out of the context of our work and our conversation.
Last night at our regular quarterly meeting the discussion turned intense as we laid out challenges, amazing opportunities and a sense of progress and momentum.
Craig Spaulding, an incredibly accomplished senior housing developer, fly fisherman and financial genius, spoke up to say, "Larry, it must be hard flying without a net for so many years."
Never before had I thought of my work in quite those terms. However, as I pondered his comment, made in the midst of his explanation of a very creative idea to provide relief for ongoing cash flow issues, I saw his point and had to agree.
We do fly without a net a good bit of the time around here!
As our meeting went on, I couldn't stop thinking about his metaphor.
Then, it hit me: "We fly without a net around here whenever we have to because the people we love so much live without nets almost all of the time."
The intermingling of ideas, values, helpful engagement and passionate concern for and connection with "our people" never ceases to amaze me.
In fact, this is the essence of CitySquare.
These wonderful men and women give so freely and sacrificially of their time, talent, money, ideas, commitment and encouragement. I recognize how fortunate I am to have the opportunity to work alongside such an amazing group of people.
At virtually every meeting of our board something encouraging, insightful, surprising and challenging comes up or is said. Most of the really exceptional stuff just arises out of the context of our work and our conversation.
Last night at our regular quarterly meeting the discussion turned intense as we laid out challenges, amazing opportunities and a sense of progress and momentum.
Craig Spaulding, an incredibly accomplished senior housing developer, fly fisherman and financial genius, spoke up to say, "Larry, it must be hard flying without a net for so many years."
Never before had I thought of my work in quite those terms. However, as I pondered his comment, made in the midst of his explanation of a very creative idea to provide relief for ongoing cash flow issues, I saw his point and had to agree.
We do fly without a net a good bit of the time around here!
As our meeting went on, I couldn't stop thinking about his metaphor.
Then, it hit me: "We fly without a net around here whenever we have to because the people we love so much live without nets almost all of the time."
The intermingling of ideas, values, helpful engagement and passionate concern for and connection with "our people" never ceases to amaze me.
In fact, this is the essence of CitySquare.
Sunday, August 18, 2013
The Neighbor
Love
Your Neighbor
The hardest spiritual work in the world is to
love the neighbor as the self–to encounter another human being not as someone
you can use, change, fix, help, save, enroll, convince or control, but simply
as someone who can spring you from the prison of yourself, if you will allow
it.
Source: An Altar in the World
Monday, August 12, 2013
Detroit and hard lessons. . .
[The demise of Detroit, Michigan provides a fairly terrifying story for other large urban areas to consider, study and evaluate in view of local challenges. This is certainly true for Dallas, Texas as we search for a new City Manager, Housing Director and City Attorney.
The following essay from Joseph E. Stiglitz offers much food for thought.
As always, I'd love your reactions. What does Detroit have to teach us all? LJ]
The Wrong Lesson From Detroit’s Bankruptcy
When I was growing up in Gary, Ind., nearly a quarter of American workers were employed in the manufacturing sector. There were plenty of jobs at the time that paid well enough for a single breadwinner, working one job, to fulfill the American dream for his family of four. He could earn a living on the sweat of his brow, afford to send his children to college and even see them rise to the professional class.
Cities like Detroit and Gary thrived on that industry, not just in terms of the wealth that it produced but also in terms of strong communities, healthy tax bases and good infrastructure. From the stable foundation of Gary’s excellent public schools, influenced by the ideas of the progressive reformer John Dewey, I went on to Amherst College and then to M.I.T. for graduate school.
Today, fewer than 8 percent of American workers are employed in manufacturing, and many Rust Belt cities are skeletons. The distressing facts about Detroit are by now almost a cliché: 40 percent of streetlights were not working this spring, tens of thousands of buildings are abandoned, schools have closed and the population declined 25 percent in the last decade alone. The violent crime rate last year was the highest of any big city. In 1950, when Detroit’s population was 1.85 million, there were 296,000 manufacturing jobs in the city; as of 2011, with a population of just over 700,000, there were fewer than 27,000.
Click here to read more.
Sunday, August 11, 2013
Tiresome
I have a place that I refer to as home, complete with running water, bathrooms, a kitchen, comfortable beds and lots of furniture, electricity, books, televisions; you know, the list goes on and on.
I have cars. Not just one, cars. Whenever I want to go somewhere, I go. Often, I fly.
I have plenty of clothing in closets--again, not just one. My sock drawer is running over, sort of like my closets. I did mention multiples, right? And shoes? Too many for one of my closets.
I've had lots of education--informal and formal, with degrees and future options for more.
I have a great family, lots of colleagues and crowds of friends.
I'm welcomed almost everywhere I go. I get lots of invitations to join folks for fun, interesting events.
People accommodate my needs, my mistakes, my selfishness and my expressed desires, almost all of the time.
When I mess things up, people pull around to compensate, to make up for the ground I've lost. Or, they confront me with my poor performance, while doing whatever it takes to get me back on track.
I am loved.
I am cared for.
I am encouraged.
___________________________________
Last Thursday, as I stood on the red hot sidewalk out at "the Corner," I watched scores of homeless friends stop by for a cold drink of water or Gatorade, a piece of fresh fruit and a snack.
One guy stood out.
He was not exceptional in any way, really. If anything, he was typical.
But, somehow I really saw him. Know what I mean?
My hunch is he is younger than me, maybe mid-50s, but he looked much older.
His shoes were broken down, run over and about shot.
He was barely limping along.
He was so very hot.
His brown jeans were filthy, as was his white shirt.
He seemed in a daze, not due to the abuse of any substance, but likely induced by too much "street" time in the heat.
I have no idea why he stood out to me.
As I directed him to a cold beverage and a snack, I was overcome with emotion.
My life circumstance flooded over me, as did what I imagined of his.
I had to brush back tears.
This is Dallas.
This is the street.
This is slow death.
This is injustice.
How I respond to that one man is the ultimate test of my faith, my life and my heart.
Friday, August 09, 2013
Press Release: CitySquare wins state award!
CitySquare Receives Governor’s Volunteer Award for Community
Leadership for Its Food on the Move
Program
Dallas, TX. August 5, 2013 --- The 30th Annual
Governor’s Volunteer Awards have been announced with CitySquare being named as
a recipient in the Community Leadership category. These awards allow the State
of Texas to recognize individuals, organizations, corporations and public
entities that truly embody the Texas tradition of community service. The
Community Leadership category recognizes an individual, group or organization
for strengthening their community through outstanding partnerships, service and
volunteerism. Community Leaders understand the importance of service and
develop connections between groups and individuals to help them craft
collaborative solutions to local needs. They exhibit a dedication to their
communities that inspires those around them to serve.
Food on the Move provides over one million meals in a
mobile feeding program targeting youth at low-income apartment sites, churches,
nonprofits, and summer camps. Funding
for the food comes through the Texas Department of Agriculture’s Summer Food
Service Program. Food on the Move
takes a stand against childhood hunger statewide, offering mobile feeding programs
in Dallas, Houston, San Antonio, and Austin. Through an innovative
collaboration with AmeriCorps, the program has delivered meals and provided
enrichment to thousands of children. The U.S. Department of Agriculture has
hailed Food on the Move “a model for
the rest of the nation.”
“Both the kids we serve and our AmeriCorps members benefit
from Food on the Move,” says Dr.
Keven Vicknair, Director of the Food on
the Move and AmeriCorps programs at CitySquare, “We are proud to be
recognized with the Community Leadership Award especially for a program that is
helping to shape young people into community leaders.”
All of the awardees will be honored on September 11th
at a private dinner with OneStar Foundation board members and other dignitaries
at the Renaissance Austin Hotel in Austin. In addition, awardees will be
recognized throughout the Texas Nonprofit Summit on September 12th and 13th
2013.
CitySquare is one of the largest, most effective faith-based
organizations in North Texas, operating a network of services and programs
focused on fighting poverty through hunger relief, health care, housing and
hope. CitySquare is the third largest summer food sponsor in the state of Texas.
A United Way agency, CitySquare is
ranked a 4-star charity by Charity Navigator with more than 92% of revenue
going directly to its programs.
#
# #
#
For more information about the event and the work of
CitySquare, please contact: Katherine Allen at 214.303.2146, kallen@CitySquare.org or Lou Ann York at 214.343.1599, lapub@sbcglobal.net .
Thursday, August 08, 2013
Employment for crew hired off "the Corner"!
I love this photo!
Jerry James (shown here on one knee in front) serves as the "foreman" for our landscape crew.
We hired each of these folks off of "the Corner" where we show up on Thursdays for refreshments, conversation and friendship creation.
Jerry comes from a tough background himself that includes time behind bars. He works as hard as anyone I've ever known. His crew follows his lead.
This group of formerly unemployed, homeless persons executed the landscape plan for the Opportunity Center that CitySquare is building at the corner of Malcolm X and I-30.
What you see here is a moment in time on a pathway to renewal and transformation.
This is our work.
Jerry James (shown here on one knee in front) serves as the "foreman" for our landscape crew.
We hired each of these folks off of "the Corner" where we show up on Thursdays for refreshments, conversation and friendship creation.
Jerry comes from a tough background himself that includes time behind bars. He works as hard as anyone I've ever known. His crew follows his lead.
This group of formerly unemployed, homeless persons executed the landscape plan for the Opportunity Center that CitySquare is building at the corner of Malcolm X and I-30.
What you see here is a moment in time on a pathway to renewal and transformation.
This is our work.
Wednesday, August 07, 2013
Tuesday, August 06, 2013
Trees
I'll confess, I've never really thought much about the value of trees.
Oh, I've often been aware of their beauty.
As a kid, I climbed among their strong branches and up their trunks, at times even attempting to construct a house in the air.
Occasionally I've cursed the unruliness of certain varieties.
And, I've enjoyed the shade provided to my mostly all-window back porch.
But as far as the personal, actual value, the utility of a tree, I've been in the dark most of my life.
Standing on "the Corner" changed that for me.
We've been out there most weeks for the past 15 months.
During that time, I've learned to take refuge under a very ugly, unwieldy tree.
But, strangely, the tree has become my friend.
In the rain, it acts as a needed umbrella.
In the heat, it provides more than welcome shade.
Even in the winter, windy cold, it blocks the sting of freezing temperatures.
As I've related to the tree, it has occurred to me that trees are in large part a generous gift to people who have no home.
I truly believe God made trees for people like the ones I meet with on "the Corner" every Thursday afternoon.
Somehow I just can't look at trees the same anymore.
Judged by the music of their songs, I expect the birds agree with me.
Oh, I've often been aware of their beauty.
As a kid, I climbed among their strong branches and up their trunks, at times even attempting to construct a house in the air.
Occasionally I've cursed the unruliness of certain varieties.
And, I've enjoyed the shade provided to my mostly all-window back porch.
But as far as the personal, actual value, the utility of a tree, I've been in the dark most of my life.
Standing on "the Corner" changed that for me.
We've been out there most weeks for the past 15 months.
During that time, I've learned to take refuge under a very ugly, unwieldy tree.
But, strangely, the tree has become my friend.
In the rain, it acts as a needed umbrella.
In the heat, it provides more than welcome shade.
Even in the winter, windy cold, it blocks the sting of freezing temperatures.
As I've related to the tree, it has occurred to me that trees are in large part a generous gift to people who have no home.
I truly believe God made trees for people like the ones I meet with on "the Corner" every Thursday afternoon.
Somehow I just can't look at trees the same anymore.
Judged by the music of their songs, I expect the birds agree with me.
Monday, August 05, 2013
We call it "reciprocity"!
Running across a statement of one of the fundamental principles/values of our organization always pulls me up short. Here is a great restatement of our belief in and insistence upon "reciprocity."
BreakingBarriers
BreakingBarriers
Breaking down the barriers between the givers
and the receivers of aid, between those who have and those who have not, is an
essential expression of the solidarity that liberates the privileged from their
blindness and the marginalized from their invisibility.
Sunday, August 04, 2013
Restoring all things. . .
A New Society
The first words about the Christian life are not
about what we as individuals can experience, but about the kind of society God
intends. The gospel, or good news, is that in Christ, God’s coming kingdom is
breaking into the here and now–in the depths of the believer’s heart, but also
in the world itself. This kingdom encompasses economic, material,
psychological, political, social and spiritual existence.
Source: "Why I Stopped Going to Church"
Friday, August 02, 2013
Thursday, August 01, 2013
Word composite
Recently, CitySquare enjoyed working with INSPIRE on a strategic thinking exercise. The entire process was provided on a probono basis. We will begin working on action steps in the very near future to activate our new learning about how to better do our work in the city.
During the process, the INSPIRE team interviewed many of our team members and customers to gain insights into our organization. One of the more fascinating outcomes of this impression tour was a "word composite" of the impressions people reported about CitySquare.
The first image below maps the responses to the prompt, "What are 3 words that best describe CitySquare?"
The second image maps answers to the question, "What are 3 words that best describe your specific program?"
Reactions?

During the process, the INSPIRE team interviewed many of our team members and customers to gain insights into our organization. One of the more fascinating outcomes of this impression tour was a "word composite" of the impressions people reported about CitySquare.
The first image below maps the responses to the prompt, "What are 3 words that best describe CitySquare?"
The second image maps answers to the question, "What are 3 words that best describe your specific program?"
Reactions?
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Sandra
Here is a report on a patient at CitySquare's Community Health Services medical clinic:
Sandra was referred to CitySquare
several years ago from the ER at Baylor. She was treated here and has
great health now.
She volunteered as a translator for our cooking classes and everyone loved her. The cooking class coordinator wanted to steal her from us.
Sandra is one of those young people brought by her parents to the US for a better life. She attended school and really did well. She went to school to be a medical assistant and her dream is to be a registered nurse. She however did not have permission to work in the US and was not eligible for scholarships or loans for college. She was stuck and unable to progress or work legally.
She volunteered as a translator for our cooking classes and everyone loved her. The cooking class coordinator wanted to steal her from us.
Sandra is one of those young people brought by her parents to the US for a better life. She attended school and really did well. She went to school to be a medical assistant and her dream is to be a registered nurse. She however did not have permission to work in the US and was not eligible for scholarships or loans for college. She was stuck and unable to progress or work legally.
In the last year there have been changes
to the rules affecting people in her situation. She quickly applied for
the Dream Act and completed all the necessary paperwork to get a work permit in
the US. We wrote letters of recommendation for her as we knew her as
patient and as a volunteer.
About a month ago she returned to the clinic to show me her Permission to work ID. She said the next day she was going to get a driver’s license. As she sat in my office, she began to cry. I asked what the matter was and she said I just can’t believe all my dreams are coming true. I have waited so long with no hope, now everything is changing so fast and it is all good.
About a month ago she returned to the clinic to show me her Permission to work ID. She said the next day she was going to get a driver’s license. As she sat in my office, she began to cry. I asked what the matter was and she said I just can’t believe all my dreams are coming true. I have waited so long with no hope, now everything is changing so fast and it is all good.
She applied for a job at Baylor at our
encouragement and she was hired for a full time position. She will, after
a period of time, be able to continue her education with the support of the
tuition reimbursement program Baylor has for employees. We are so proud
of what she has accomplished.
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
Public schools and poverty
Poverty Is What's Crippling Public Education in the U.S.—Not Bad Teachers
- ANTHONY CODY
- 1:34 PM ET
- COMMENTS
Earlier this month in New Zealand, Minister of Education Hekia Parata shared a piece of knowledge that has become common the world over. In the Southland Times, “Experts have found that four consecutive years of quality teaching eliminated any trace of socio-economic disadvantage.”
The source of this is an American economist by the name of Eric Hanushek, a professor at Stanford University, who has been spreading this for the past several years. According to Hanushek, "Good teachers are ones who get large gains in student achievement for their classes; bad teachers are just the opposite."
He looks at the distribution of student test scores, and imagines that if we could fire the teachers who are associated with the lowest 10 percent or so, then we would make huge gains. This is the theory behind a great deal of the push for 21st century K-12 education reform in the US. In order to identify and efficiently dispatch these slackers, we need national standards, and rigorous tests aligned to them.
This has led reformers to advocate that we:
- Test students more often, so we can measure learning incrementally. Test students in every subject, and at every grade level—even kindergarten, so that all teachers can be properly judged.
- Eliminate barriers to firing the "bad teachers" who get low scores, so due process and seniority protections have to go.
- Create new evaluation plans that give significant weight to "value added" measures drawn from test scores, for both teachers and administrators.
Hanushek has also argued, by the way, that more money won’t help schools succeed, nor will small class size. The teacher is the only variable worth targeting. Unions are a problem to the extent to which they make it difficult to quickly fire teachers identified as ineffective.
But the real world is proving to be a difficult place for Hanushek’s theories to be verified. No school has ever replicated the results predicted by his "four great teachers in a row" theory. In fact, there is no real research to support the idea that we can improve student achievement this way—it is all based on extrapolations.
And in fact, new data shows that in the three large urban school districts where these reforms have been given full rein, the results are actually worse than in comparable districts that have not gone this route.
Some of the key findings from the Economic Policy Institute’s April report:
- Test scores increased less, and achievement gaps grew more, in “reform” cities than in other urban districts.
- Test-based accountability prompted churn that thinned the ranks of experienced teachers, but not necessarily bad teachers.
- School closures did not send students to better schools or save school districts money.
Most importantly:
- The reforms missed a critical factor driving achievement gaps: the influence of poverty on academic performance.
This last point is crucial. This attention to the supposedly pivotal role teachers play in student success comes at a time when the number of children in poverty has been on the rise. According to a study in 2011 (pdf), one school in five was considered high poverty, up from one in eight in the year 2000. Another study showed that "many high-poverty schools receive less than their fair share of state and local funding… leav(ing) students in high-poverty schools with fewer resources than schools attended by their wealthier peers."
While conservative economists such as Hanushek wish to focus our attention on "bad teachers," in actuality by far the largest factor affecting school performance is family income. In fact, the achievement gap between rich and poor has grown to be twice as large as the black/white performance gap in America.
Teachers are important, and of course we want to recruit the most expert and brightest possible, and give them lots of support. But the expansion of tests, and efforts to make teacher jobs depend on ever-rising scores, are turning our schools into test preparation factories.
Hanushek’s ideas have been driving a vast school reform project, which has been underwritten by the largest philanthropies on earth—starting with the Gates and Walton foundations. Now that this project is a decade old, and showing little signs of success, the time has come for a major reappraisal.
Rather than vesting our trust in tests to identify and weed out the worst teachers, why not invest some confidence in these teachers themselves, and empower them to engage in peer observation and growth through proven programs like Peer Assistance and Review? These programs feature experienced teacher coaches working with peers who have been identified as struggling. This has been found to be an effective way to strengthen teachers—and remove those who are unable to improve.
And how about some direct action to reduce the extreme income gap between wealthy and poor? An increase in the minimum wage would provide increased stability to millions of families, which would help children focus on their studies instead of where their next meal will come from. Most schools have cut nurses, librarians and counselors, at the same time we are expanding our investment in measurement systems.
So I offer this warning to the people down under and beyond. This misguided emphasis is no more likely to work there than it has in the US—unless of course, New Zealand truly is “opposite land,” where hot snow falls up.
This post originally appeared on Quartz, an Atlantic partner site.
Monday, July 29, 2013
Stupid ideas. . .
Hunger Makes People Work Harder, and Other Stupid Things We Used to Believe About Poverty
Read the article here.
Saturday, July 27, 2013
Friday, July 26, 2013
Street stuff. . .
Thursday on "the Corner" turned out extremely hot and humid.
We enjoyed the presence of some guests who came to "hang out"--a couple of young business people with an idea for locating a manufacturing facility in the S. Dallas/Fair Park area; six CitySquare team members besides myself. Then of course, the "parade" of scores of homeless friends who passed by, took advantage of the ice water and the conversation.
People seemed exceptionally weak today:
We enjoyed the presence of some guests who came to "hang out"--a couple of young business people with an idea for locating a manufacturing facility in the S. Dallas/Fair Park area; six CitySquare team members besides myself. Then of course, the "parade" of scores of homeless friends who passed by, took advantage of the ice water and the conversation.
People seemed exceptionally weak today:
- A sixty-year-old man with severe glaucoma which creates blindness that he can't afford to treat
- A chronically homeless woman who has become a regular at "the Corner" suffering from what may be walking pneumonia
- Several men and women with physical and psychological disorders who need treatment and can't seem to get it
- A woman who graduated from an overcoming drug abuse program but who needs housing desperately
- Several folks who went through our housing enrollment process who need housing so badly
- Hungry, hungry people
- Hot, tired, discouraged people
- People asking again and again for work
- A friend who is a chronic inebriate, but a friend who blessed me again, as he always does
- A friend whose 90-year-old mother came by with his sister--he hadn't seen them in months--tearful
My buddy Joe, when asked by one of our staff members if we could help him, instructed the "people helper" with his ckipboard that "I'm taking over the conversation."
Joe made my staff guy sit down. He then said to him, "Sir, may I help you? We have cold water if you'd like some."
Our staff guy answered wisely, "Yes, I'd love some water."
Joe retrieved a bottle of water and delivered it to his new friend with flourish.
"There you are, sir," Joe declared. "May I help you in some other way?"
The entire production was to drive home the point that being asked if you need help again and again gets really old, especially when you know you could help yourself and anyone else if you had the chance provided by the resources.
Worn out by people offering to "help" you. There is a new notion, but one so true.
Thursday, July 25, 2013
Donor concern: Hatred? Really?
Rev. Gerald Britt published another compelling essay in The Dallas Morning News yesterday. His comments focused on the tragic Trayvon Martin incident. I hope you'll read and consider his thoughts here.
I received the following email from a person who has been a long-time CitySquare donor. I found it amazing and thoroughly disappointing. Here's what he said along with my reply and his final word:
Larry,
I received the following email from a person who has been a long-time CitySquare donor. I found it amazing and thoroughly disappointing. Here's what he said along with my reply and his final word:
Larry,
Trayvon Martin's killing brought on a lot of debate, some healthy and constructive, some unhealthy and destructive. Gerald Britt's article in this morning's paper is the most hate-filled, irrational article I have seen from either side of the issue. Take me off of your lists. I can't support an organization that is actively promoting hate in our community.
Signed his name
____________________________________________
Thank you for contacting me with your opinion about Rev. Britt’s editorial.
Frankly, your reaction is surprising to me. I can’t find the hatred to which you refer anywhere in the article. It would be helpful to me if you could elucidate more specifically to what you are referring. I would love to talk to you by phone or face-to-face, as I am sure Gerald would as well.
As I have considered the entire case, my question is why didn’t young Trayvon Martin fall under the protection of the “stand your ground” law in Florida? He was pursued by an armed stranger. If he “stood his ground” in his own defense, how could he be blamed and how could an armed assailant be declared “not guilty.”
Again, please direct me to the hatred or to the irrationality of Gerald’s article. I really need your help on this one.
Best regards,
Larry
___________________________________________
Thanks Larry, That's all I needed to
know. If that article speaks for City Square, we're done.
Signed his name
___________________________________________
I'm trying folks, really, I am. But, I can't see or hear the "hatred."
Can you?
The fact that we can't have a sensible conversation is a huge tip off that we have a major problem about race and culture in this nation.
Sad.
Wednesday, July 24, 2013
Tuesday, July 23, 2013
Poverty, middle class and the cost of living. . .
This just in from The Huffington Post:
The Economic Policy Institute has just updated their cost-of-living budgets to reflect how much a family needs to earn to get by in 2013.
Looking at over 600 locations and estimating community-specific costs, EPI found that families need more than twice the amount of the federal poverty line to have a secure yet modest living standard.
"Our family budget calculations show that the real costs for families to live modest -- not even middle class -- lives are much higher than conventional estimates show and virtually impossible for families living on minimum-wage jobs," said Elise Gould, the Economic Policy Institute director of health policy research.
Read more here.
Monday, July 22, 2013
Out of poverty via hard work? Not so fast, buddy!
[We've always thought that the way out of poverty is hard work. Not so fast there. The way out of poverty is hard work at a living wage job. Those jobs aren't nearly as available as many of us surmise. In fact, more and more people are working hard and slipping deeper into poverty. It's more accurate to say that the way out of poverty is two, full-time jobs! Read the following report. You'll see what I mean. LJ]
McDonald's Can't Figure Out How Its Workers Survive on Minimum Wage
JORDAN WEISSMANNJUL
In a financial planning guide for its workers, the company accidentally illustrates precisely how impossible it is to scrape by on a fast food paycheck.
Well this is both embarrassing and deeply telling. In what appears to have been a gesture of goodwill gone haywire, McDonald's recently teamed up with Visa to create a financial planning site for its low-pay workforce. Unfortunately, whoever wrote the thing seems to have been literally incapable of imagining of how a fast food employee could survive on a minimum wage income.
As ThinkProgress and other outlets have reported, the site includes a sample budget that, among other laughable assumptions, presumes that workers will have a second job.
Read the entire report here.
McDonald's Can't Figure Out How Its Workers Survive on Minimum Wage
JORDAN WEISSMANNJUL
In a financial planning guide for its workers, the company accidentally illustrates precisely how impossible it is to scrape by on a fast food paycheck.
Well this is both embarrassing and deeply telling. In what appears to have been a gesture of goodwill gone haywire, McDonald's recently teamed up with Visa to create a financial planning site for its low-pay workforce. Unfortunately, whoever wrote the thing seems to have been literally incapable of imagining of how a fast food employee could survive on a minimum wage income.
As ThinkProgress and other outlets have reported, the site includes a sample budget that, among other laughable assumptions, presumes that workers will have a second job.
Read the entire report here.
Sunday, July 21, 2013
Throwing different kinds of parties. . .
Luke 14:12-14
New Revised Standard Version (NRSV)
12 He said also to the one who had invited him, “When you give a luncheon or a dinner, do not invite your friends or your brothers or your relatives or rich neighbors, in case they may invite you in return, and you would be repaid. 13 But when you give a banquet, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, and the blind.14 And you will be blessed, because they cannot repay you, for you will be repaid at the resurrection of the righteous.”
1. Who do we normally invite to our parties? Why so?
2. What happens when we do? Any surprises?
3. What might happen if we threw different kinds of parties with different "guest lists"? What would that be like? What would be uncomfortable? Why? What would be positive? Why?
4. Where does "repayment" take place in the work of compassion and justice?
1. Who do we normally invite to our parties? Why so?
2. What happens when we do? Any surprises?
3. What might happen if we threw different kinds of parties with different "guest lists"? What would that be like? What would be uncomfortable? Why? What would be positive? Why?
4. Where does "repayment" take place in the work of compassion and justice?
Saturday, July 20, 2013
Arkansas and the Ozarks
Ran across this photo of the look out from Petit Jean Mountain across the Arkansas River valley.
Enjoyed my years as a student in Arkansas and at Harding College (now University).
Lots of beauty there, and so many good people.
I love the hills and foothills of Arkansas!
Friday, July 19, 2013
Insightful tool. . .
I found an insightful tool regarding family income and budgeting.
Take a look here!
Looking for reactions!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


.jpg)










